Hum Dramas & The Complicated Art of the Girl Tragedy

This research focuses on the significance of the HUM drama in the lives of its female viewers, specifically considering its affective value and its role in shaping community and interpersonal, especially intergenerational dialogue. It particularly hones in on the narratives and viewership experiences of these women, connecting with them directly to ask “What do these dramas mean to you? What roles do they play in your life?”

By centering the gazes and voices of these viewers, this article aims to add to the existing literature (and criticisms) of the HUM Drama from a position that is rooted within the community, and ultimately to “speak with” rather than “speak at”, when it comes to understanding the value, impact and criticisms of the HUM Drama as a form. To approach this, the research relies on primary outreach frameworks, specifically surveys and interviews, that allow direct contact with female viewers, focusing on their patterns of viewership, affective insights and evaluations of the drama. To supplement this, the research refers to a number of theoretical frameworks to underscore the significance of television in building sociality and the experience of “family time”, gain quantitative insights about the impact of HUM dramas on Pakistani audiences, and identify the major criticisms and thematic analyses of the HUM Drama. Beyond this, the article also touches upon the broader affective significance of different forms of the drama, particularly the telenovela across cultures. Through my research, the role of the HUM Drama as a site of leisure, recognition, communication and discomfort became evident. Its multi-layered presence and functions in the lives of its viewers, and the range of affects that it cultivates, exist in tandem. It is not seen or engaged with as a perfect form, rather an evolving product, at times deeply disappointing, at times rich with potential and movement. These dimensions and complexities, I argued and found, could be uniquely and effectively witnessed only through a sincere engagement with the gaze of female Pakistani viewers.

SWG
Author
Mina Shoaib